Followers

28 July, 2010

An Advice to those in Pakistan Army!


Those who do not judge according to that which Allah has sent down are the evildoers, harmdoers, unbelieveres. (Surah Al Maida 5:44,45 and 47)

Have you not seen those who befriend a people on whom Allah's wrath? They are neither of you nor of them, and they swear falsely while they know. Allah has prepared for them a severe punishment; surely what they do is evil.  


Muslims around the globe are facing a weird situation. We have around 50 Muslim Majority countries around the world, which are 'Islamic Republics' in the paper-work but there is no true Islamic Country on this gloomy globe. We are being lead by kings, prime-ministers, presidents or military leaders who are ruling us by a muddle of secular and divine laws. We are made to spend our lives in systems that have no concern for the Islamic sprit and rulings. We do our utmost to save ourselves from polytheistic activities (involving shirk) but doing nothing to transform this system which is continuously feeding our minds and bodies with polytheistic dust.
Those who do not judge according to that which Allah has sent down are the evildoers, harmdoers, unbelieveres. (Surah Al Maida 5:44,45 and 47)
    Islam is not a mere set of traditions and customs, it is a complete code of personal and social life, hence, a total socio-economic system. These divine laws were revealed to become the foundation of Islamic governments at-first, and then encompass the whole world. The Muslim countries have ignored the perfect divine laws and imposed the modern secular blend on themselves. We, the money-making robots, don't realize the gravity of the situation because our own personal lives are void of Islamic spirit. The 'religious' amongst us are pretty staunch on the Islamic laws regarding personal life but unknowingly they are doing much more to serve and strengthen this unislamic system than they are doing for its reformation of revolution.
    This prelude was essential to highlight the difference between the world-view of those who are unplugged and those who are still 'connected' . The former is buried under the intense responsibility of giving light to this gloomy globe. He sees no good in strengthening the current systems. He's proud of injecting religion into everything. He has a single mode of life, whether he's at work, at school, at his home, the first and fore-most thing on his mind is the responsibility to establish the law of Allah in every corner of the world. On the contrary, the connected ones have multi-modes of life. Religion seems good to them in the worship place or on religious days, but they close their eyes from all evils in the practical life. They are busy in making a living, and don't really bother from where the money comes and who they are serving. Working in banks and brothels is an act of blasphemy to them, but they don't find any problem in serving the anti-Islamic governments and American companies.
    The case-study that we have in this document is that of Pakistan Army. Those who cannot listen anything against the immune organization which their fore-fathers served should simply close this document and pray for their own hidayah. For others, I hereby declare that I am an extremist who sees everything first in light of the Islamic spirit, and then extend it in line with logic and wisdom. Oh Allah! Give us all the understanding of religion.

 
Mission of an Islamic Army:
An Islamic Army protects the Islamic states and strives to extend the Islamic rule throughout the globe by fighting the oppressors. In the current world as there is no Islamic state so the purpose of an Islamic Army would be first to establish an Islamic State. Prophet Muhammad SAW fought a series of battles in Madinah until they finally established the first Islamic state after the conquest of Makkah. Pakistan Army is doing exact opposite of what it is supposed to do. It is protecting the un-Islamic state and fighting against those who are striving for an Islamic State. My brothers, the rebels are not those whom you murdered in Lal Masjid or Swat Valley on the American orders just because they were holding the flag of Islamic Law, the rebels are those who have hijacked this state and are using it to glorify their banks and homes.
Prophet Muhammad SAW so beautifully summarized the mission of a Mujahid :
" He who fights to make the Kalimah of Allah the supreme, is on the path of Allah" (Sahih Muslim).
I urge you all to go and conduct a survey, ask those in army, who has heard this hadith? They don't know their own slogan and motto dedicated to them by Prophet Muhammad SAW. They don't envision the spring of Islam, and a Global Islamic State. This leaves us with no other option but to conclude that they have some other mission. They are serving army for their family, their nation, but certainly they are void of the Islamic vision.
Prophet Muhammad SAW said, " Prophethood shall remain among you as long as Allah wishes. Then, Allah will raise it when he wishes. Then, shall come a khilafah according to the path of Prophets. It shall last amongst you as long as Allah wishes. Then, Allah will raise it when he wishes. Then, shall come biting (long-period) kingdoms. It shall last amongst you as long as Allah wishes. Then, Allah will raise it as he wishes. Then, shall come military (power-controlled) kingdoms. It shall last amongst you as long as Allah wishes. Then, Allah will raise it when he wishes. Then, shall come a Khilafah according to the path of the Prophets. Then, he kept quiet" (Narrated by Ahmed, Authenticated by al-Albani in Silsilitul Ahadith us Saheeha)

 
Protecting Muslims from Non-Muslims Oppression
Pakistani Army has been protecting the Kashmiri's from the Indian Aggression since the last sixty years. This has been viewed as a great service throughout the Muslim world. No doubt, this task needs to be done, but there are few questions that come in my mind.
Point # 1 – Protecting the Kashmiri's from Indian oppression but not doing anything to turn over the un-Islamic rule in your own home means that we are just striving to maintain them as a part of this Muslim Secular State. They cannot practice full-Islam if they are a part of India, they cannot practice full-Islam if they are a part of Pakistan. They would continuously be dealing in Riba, they'd be forced to pay taxes, they'd be made to solve their disputes in un-Islamic courts.
Point # 2 – The Kashmiri riots provoke us, but the Gujrati riots don't. What is the reason for that?
Point # 3 – Isn't it a must on the Army to go and strive against the American and Israeli aggression in Afghanistan, Iraq and Palestine?
Forming Military Alliances with Non-Muslims
Instead of Helping the Muslims against American aggression in Afghanistan, we helped the American army in bulldozing Afghanistan. We provided them our bases and commandoes and the army-escorted NATO supply is on the move since. And this is no hidden truth. We did all this openly. So, where does the Pakistan Army stand now? After serving Satan instead of Allah, preferring non-Muslims over Muslims, and forming a military alliance with non-Muslims against Muslims, this is where the army stands:
O you who believe! do not take the Jews and the Christians for friends; they are friends of each other; and whoever amongst you takes them for a friend, then surely he is one of them; surely Allah does not guide the unjust people. (Surah Al Maida – 5:51)
Those who prefer non-Muslims amongst Muslims are counted as non-Muslims in the sight of Allah. Mufti Nizam ad din Shamzai said," It is not permissible for a Muslim in any land, be he government employee or any thing else to put forward any assistance of any type that was for the American aggression against Afghanistan, especially when this attack is compromised of Crusade Onslaught against Muslim Afghanistan. Any Muslim that extends any assitance in this aggression is considered an apostate from Din". No one can save himself from sin totally these days. Prophet SAW had prophesized this in a hadith :
A time is certainly coming to mankind when only the receiver of usury will remain, and if he does not receive it, some of its vapour will reach him. Ibn Isa said: Some of its dust will reach him. (Sunan Abu Dawud)
We need to save ourselves,the much possible from this system of taghoot. How can we ever think of joining forces which are striving to strengthen and protect this system of taghoot, whereas the need of the hour is to overturn this system and implement the divine laws ? Would we wish to join an institution which is helping non-Muslims bulldoze Muslims? How can we join an institution which sells Muslims to American Forces? How can we join hands with those who are against the flag bearers for Islam? How can we join those whose Kufr has been exposed when they supported American Army against Muslims again and again?
Training of an Islamic Army
What is in the roots of our army men? What sort of training do they get? Are they trained the way Prophet Muhammad trained his army? Is it possible that we sow wheat grains and we get sugar canes out of it?
Army training starts from PMA Kakool, a place where new-comers are bombarded with –galiyan-. The first thing they learn are new dimensions in the dictionary of immodest words. Those who say a few prayers in the academy are considered pious monks. There is no religious training. No one teaches them fiqh of Jihad. No effort is made for spiritual elevation. Hollywood and Bollywood is their entertainment. Cigarette is their dose. Very few would turn up when Azaan is recited. These are obvious truths, that no one can deny. Is this the way Muslim army used to be at the times of Prophet Muhammad? Were they not the highest in the spiritual status?
The immense contrast in the Army of Sahaba and the Pakistan Army forces one to think, what are they fighting for? The Sahaba would not even leave Salah in the battle field, and they prefer chilling out in their rooms rather than responding to the call of Allah. The love for Allah made the Army of Sahaba Disciplined, and the Pakistan Army is forcefully disciplined by mental and physical tortures. When they don't implement Islam in their own lives, how can they hold the flag of spreading Islam in the world? When they don't turn up for Salah, but stand still in respect of the national anthem, one is forced to think, who are they serving?
The Neutral Trap
' Ok ! The Army is wrong, I know. But, so is every other organization of this country. Every organization is corrupt'. This is the pet argument of army men. Dust is all around. No one can save himself totally from it. A sane person, and a true Muslim has to skid by the worldly requirements of earning a living and give the rest of his time to a noble mission of establishing the rule of Allah. Can we select our job so carelessly? Can we start any other job before starting the job assigned to us by Allah?
Your house is unclean. You were supposed to clean it up yourselves. You are not doing the job yourselves and you are wiping out those who wish to take up this job themselves. You still think your job is neutral?
The Individual Mission Trap
' Everyone in army is not same, there are very pious people in army as well'. Pakistan Army has seen people who were truly motivated by the Islamic spirit. Many people have sacrificed their lives, deeming it to by martyrdom in the path of Allah. May Allah forgive them for their ignorance and accept their efforts.
Some people just need a platform to sacrifice their lives for Allah, and without careful thinking they select this as the path. The Islamic socio-economic vision is very scarce in the present world. In this age of confusion, misinformation and very little Islamic education it is expected that people would be doing things with and Islamic intention, but in actual serving the satanic missions.
Would you ever join a brothel, to educate people on the prohibition of wine? Is it allowed to work in a music-band to tell people that music is prohibited? Is it sane to join army with an 'individual' mission ignoring what the mission of the army is?
If you are motivated by the Islamic spirit, then why don't you join any amongst the wide-range of movements and groups working for the Islamic revival? Look inside, judge yourself. Have you not joined army for material gains?
One can be either with those who are striving for the Islamic revival or one would be directly or indirectly against them. This is the gift of the global village. You are involved in strengthening one of the two systems: the secular or the divine. Are you ready to meet your lord on the day of judgment having spent your life in strengthening man-made systems?
The touch-stone of Success
"I swear by the time, Most surely man is in loss, Except those who believe and do good, and enjoin on each other truth, and enjoin on each other patience." (Surah Al Asr – 103)
The Surah tells us four must-have qualities of successful person . (1) He should have faith, (2) He should strive to establish Islam in his own self, (3) he should strive in a group to establish Islam in the world and (4) he should be patient and stead-fast on this and enjoin on others, the same. Anyone who misses out any of the ingredients of success, is actually in loss. The Surah gives us clear guidelines on how to select our path in life.
And the touch-stone of Successful Organization (group of people) is :
(They are) those who, if We establish them in the land, establish regular prayer and give regular charity, enjoin the right and forbid wrong: with Allah rests the end (and decision) of (all) affairs. (Surah Al Hajj – 22:41)
They are those whom when Allah gives power, do their very best to establish the socio-economic and worship system of Islam, and try to inculcate Islam in the lives of People by enjoining the Good and forbidding the prohibited.
Hence, striving for establishment of an Islamic state is not a choice. It is a must do work.
Prophet Muhammad SAW said , " He, who died in such a state that he never participated in Jihad and never intended it in the heart, died in a degree of hypocrisy" (Sunan Abu Dawud)


Prophet Muhammad SAW said , " He, who never participated in Jihad or financed a Mujahid or looked after a Mujahid's family in his absence, then Allah will put him in some difficulty" (Sunan Abu Dawud)
May Allah give us all the understanding of religion and put our name amongst those who strive to make the Kalimah of Allah the Highest. May Allah make us all momin, mohsin and mujahid.


Author : Mohammad Awais Tahir

The author may or may not have the same views on the topic and would not like to be quoted on what has been said above. The author, however, deems nothing wrong with changing opinions, hence, he does not wish to amend/remove posts that do not resonate with his current thinking. 
“Those who never retract their opinions love themselves more than they love truth.”


Send your comments and suggestions to feedback@exploringpsyche.com

Get Updates for New Post:

26 comments:

Bela said...

U have left me speechless :(

Muhammad Awais Tahir said...

Why the ':('...

Qasim Ali said...

Appreciating, sir. I, among the soldiers preaching in brothels, need suggestions. what should be done when there are bomb blasts, shattering the 1000 families apart at once, an Islamic State do.?
Should we leave it as a routine blast or search for its root cause?
the only doubt keeps my wear those flashes.

We should at least go there to check it, if the hypocrites, being funded by agencies, the real knaves led agencies, will mention the real threats or will b happy to keep feeding those innocents with evil thoughts.

I know we were wrong, in Lal Masjid's case, yeah damn wrong, i would never ever gonna prove any thing in its favor. But what had to b done to stop the blasts?? else going there and searching the roots.

The training is no way is given the Islam taught us. I want u to pray for we evils, to b enlightened with the right path.

No one here even bothers to take Athan seriously, when will we enter the Mosque. May Allah forgive us and bring us to right track. Amen

Mansur Khurasani said...

u r rite on many acounts but not so on the core issue dat concerns the institution in these times.

Agreed da basic structure of the system wich trains these men has many viruses. From da language they listen and use @ the academy to their usual life style and so on ... but they have done more 4 the down-trodden Ummah even in recent years than the band of people led by those who appear only in rare footages and 'inspire' the youth 'who don't get the Quran down their throats'.

Not long ago I was @ par with the ideas that underly ur writing but some weeks in the very fields and mountains where those whom you deem to hold the flag of Islam fight this Army have changed my opinion- only about the 'core issue'.

How is it that the only people who were able to form a state on the basic principles of Shariat Muhammadi and who were dislogded 'with the help' of this Army don't condemn it while those who out of their unchecked enthusiasm have only brought troubles to Muslim majority states (and almost without an exception the people who suffered were common people and not the pillars of those 'taghooti states') and those who have nothing on the ground 2 show as their service to Islam r all out 2, not merely criticize but, malign it? Y is it so? Is it not true? r the facts not exactly as I said? If they r, and surely they r, have you ever reflected on this?

The difference is being on the ground with an objective aim considering the realities of the time.

no sensible person would ever say that this Army has semblance with the army of Sahaba. no, this can never b

But let me tell u the wars of the 21st century are also not Badr and Uhud. Here I only mean that the wars in these times are not necessarily fought head-on and more recently they have not been.

They may have adopted wrong policies in certain battles and perhaps they have but in the War as a whole they have planned and till now fought well.

What if this army had declared War on US? perhaps no one could then term it as taghooti army and we may have brought US to knees even though it may have cost millions of lives and the whole infrastructure as in iraq. Such losses could never be avoided. So what if the aim of defeating the invaders is achieved through other possible means with relatively far less losses? Its not allowed to form alliances with kaafirs, right, but whats the reason? i believe it is not to strengthen them and help them attain an upper hand, right? what if the alliance some way helps u in upholding this purpose especially considering the long term scenario?

I do not claim to be a wali, sufi or sumthing like that nor do i talk to u of spiritual forces, I speak on the basis of my observations and scrutiny of the news items, reports and what i saw, felt and heard in the land where 6 agencies have largely been defeated by 1. And irony is that many like u think the very same agency to be mercenary force only.

And to clarify: I don't wear khaki, neither I have ever been paid a single penny by the army nor have my fore-fathers served in it. moreover, i have nothing in common with the some die-hard blind patriots. Its only that I have been observing temporal realities without much speculation.

While u must study the realities deeply & if posible visit the regions where this Army fights, wait till the drop seen of the whole show comes to light; for ends justify the means.

geting into brothel & preaching against wine and joing a music band like analogies not only show ur wit & writing skills but also ur inability to grasp the realities of modern warfare.

making blog posts, drawing room discussions & even attaining ur personal jannah through a blind jihad is far more easy than planning a war with least resources and taking on armies of the world.

Muhammad Awais Tahir said...

Point # 1 - Such brutal and indiscriminate terror activities will not happen if there was a truly 'Islamic' State.

Point # 2 - First clear your own hypocrisy then talk about others hypocrisy. Our state is a hypocrite state. This is the wrath of Allah, for we did not fulfill our promise. We got a land to practice Islam and then started implement secular laws here. This rule has been declared by Allah in Surah At Tawbah. Those who make false promises with Allah. Allah puts hypocrisy in their hearts.

Point # 3 - Foreign Elements are here because we are inviting them. When we allow America to operate here. Isn't america foreign? Isn't america our Enemy? Is it our own will to declare who is terrorist and who is not? Are we not taking orders from America on this.

Point # 4 - Start thinking on 'ideas' and 'systems' rather than events. Small minds discuss people, middle minds discuss events, and genius minds discuss ideas. So, see the bigger picture and decide your path in its light. Don't discuss events.

Point # 5 - Try and read the article again.

Point # 6 - Qasim, I wanted to say all this to you directly, but for the fear that you might mind I didn't. Now, Its there for you to read again and again.

Point # 7 - May Allah show us all the true path. May Allah make us of those who strive to make the Kalimah of Allah as the highest.

Muhammad Awais Tahir said...

1- I won't comment on each and every thing you have mentioned brother Mansur, because it all revolves around the ground realities and events. No doubt ground realities and events play a part in our strategy but they never allow us to go against the basics. Pakistan Army does not has in its base what an Islamic army has.

2- Yes, no army can be equivalent to the army of the sahaba. But an Islamic Army should be based on the same principles 'at least'.

3- 21st centruy might have changed the looks and the systems of the world but the Allah and his Help is still the same if we call for it and not call 'others' for help whom Allah has declared as our enemies so many times in the Qur'an.

"fiza e badr paida ker, farishtay taire nusrat ko
utar saktay hain gardoon say,
qataar andar, qataar, AB BHE "

4- The ultimate result of the alliance is that they demolished Afghanistan and now they are killing innocents every day through the drone attacks. These are the vivid news and many hidden ones as well which I won't discuss here.

5- I am not astonished that you are not among the same force, for I see people not succeeding in throwing the massive curtains thrown on our eyes by the current era of disinformation.

6- An advice, is to first read what an Islamic Army looks like, what it does. What are the 'constants of Jihad' that never change. What are the 'variable of Jihad'. And try to realize that all the compromise that we are doing are on the 'constants' and not on the variables. We can't expect Allah's help by continually disobeying the rules that He made for us. Before you leave any other comment. Listen to the lecture of Imam Anwar Awlaki , 'Constants of Jihad'. No logic can supersede the orders of Allah, for they are the most logical, though we don't understand.

7- There is no concept of 'Personal Jannah' in Islam. We all have to fulfill some religious obligations that are related to the society and systems.

Muhammad Awais Tahir said...

8- The age of materialism has successfully emptied people from religious beliefs. Struggle for materials is increasing drastically, ultimately, efforts for spiritual up-lift and conception of the spiritual essence have been alarmingly minimized. We live in a society where the majority is spiritually dead. There are hearts which are still burning. Through a very wicked and planned misinformation propaganda a very wide-gap has been created between their understanding of religious rituals and socio-economic systems. Lives are being spent in mere preparation of one’s own self. This is just a ‘part’ and first step of the holy struggle. Having freed one’s own self from the cage of materialism, one has to strive to unplug other’s the same way, and transform the ungodly systems into those which are built on foundations taken from divine guidance. The end goal is the transformation of this gloomy globe into a enlightened one. This complete struggle is ‘Jihad’. It starts from one’s own self, and the domain stretches until the vision is actualized, the vision of a peaceful world, free of disbelief and corruption. Islam is not complete without this struggle. Don’t be fooled by the peace-card. The actual peace lovers are those who strive for the supremacy of divine laws, for only they ensure peace. Let us learn the mechanics of the Holy Effort (Jihad) directly from Qur’an and Hadith.

9- Yes, there 'might' be people doing blind Jihad, but majority who are 'really' doing Jihad keep in view the ground realities. But, yes they don't compromise on the constants and this is what 'hurts' most of us. And it’s a sad thing that whenever one uses the word 'Jihad' , the majority directly thinks about the 'blind jihad'. Even the muslims equate terrorism with Jihad now. People have to clarify on television , " No, No, I don't support any terrorist organization "

10- We have the source (if we realize) which no non-muslim army has that is the help of Allah SWT. As long as we keep aside the nusrah of Allah totally aside, and keep on waiting for the right time, the situation will only get worse as we are seeing it. Prophet SAW had already prophesized the Qitaal (Jihaad bis Saif) will never cease, and they'd be people doing at all times. But, yes others would sit in their homes getting indoctrinated by the american-media war, and equating jihad with terrorism.

11- Read these Ayaat too : Surah Hud 11:13, Surah Ale Imran 3:28,118, Surah Al Maida 5:57, 80-81, Surah An Nisa 4:144, Surah Mujadila 14-22, Surah Mumtahina 60:1.

12- May Allah Guide us All!

Mansur Khurasani said...

Will write in detail about Jihad and its Fiqh. I have learned all this from ulema and scholars who make a comprehensive study of Islam i.e. the orthodoxy u may like to call who established the true system in Afghanistan and know it is coming again and this time spreading to east as well.

As to the constants of Jihad. most important that it should lead the awful defeat of the forces of disbelief and victory for Muslims..

and remember "al-harb khid'a"

as to drone attacks, its about suffering some loss instead of grave loss. The very 'unislamic' state is a problem for the invaders more than even taliban and only mujahideen on ground and with greater objectives understand the implications of unthoughtful actions..

as to my disinformation: i am quite confident you perhaps never stepped into even peaceful areas of FATA like Khyber agency i have spent months in the hills with bloodiest encounters between ur 'holders of flag of islam' and the 'unislamic army'...

Mesam said...

There is none, but one true Islamic state, the fear of which has truly taken roots in the hearts of the enemies of Islam... The fruits of whose struggle are seen in Lebanon, and in Palestine in the form of Hezbullah and Hamas...

Muhammad Awais Tahir said...

I am not here to clarify my own position. I know about my links, knowledge and journeys. When you say something sensible I'd reply.

Once again, you show how badly you are affected by the media war and how immensly ruined by the knowledge of state-sponsored ulema.

Read all the constants first, read all the Ayaat first. Contemplate yourself also. Don't feed your mind with one-sided view of scholars of your choice. Get the simple and direct message of Qur'an yourself first.

Muhammad Awais Tahir said...

It is you who should ask yourself first.

- How many Ayaat of Qur'an related to Jihad and Qitaal have you read yourself?

- How many Scholars of Tanzeem e Islami, Tehreek e Islami, Al - Qaeda, Hizb ut Tahrir have you listened to yourself?

- Have you ever listened to Abdullah Azzam, Anwar Awalki?

- Have you read the Tafaseer of Ayaat related to Jihad and Qitaal yourself?

- Have you ever tried to find the Jam'aat which is prophecized in the hadith to strive for freedom of Al Quds?

- Have you ever tried to find the constants in Sahaba's Jihad and map it over the movements of the day?

- Have you learnt about the motives of Talibaan directly from their people rather than what media spoon feeds you with?


Don't fall in the trap of those scholars who are ready to use the 'wisdom-card' wherever they will.

Mansur Khurasani said...

//"Once again, you show how badly you are affected by the media war and how immensly ruined by the knowledge of state-sponsored ulema."//

Do you believe that all ulema who do not subscribe to your opinion are state sponsored?

//"Don't fall in the trap of those scholars who are ready to use the 'wisdom-card' wherever they will."//

More than 100 scholars of all schools of though gathered in Jami Ashrafia few months back and although they criticized the way govt has dealt with the situation they rejected violence in the name of Islam against the state. Do you reject all those ulema? Do you believe they are state sponsored?

Muhammad Awais Tahir said...

I know precisely what those scholars said. That by no means goes parallel with what you are presenting here.

But, Yes, Prophet Muhammad prophecized that hypocrite scholars will come, and yes we are living in that age.

One cannot paint everyone with the same brush, don't go to irrational points!

Muhammad Awais Tahir said...

People who have no knowledge of what Islam demands from us confuse people by using the words like 'peace', 'violence', 'violent islam', 'blind jihad', 'baghawat', 'qanoon hath main laina' etc etc.

When discussing such important matters, one should terminologies of Qur'an and Hadith, and not use these emotional tools.

YES, CUTTING OFF THE SECULAR ORDER AND REPLACING IT WITH THE DIVINE IS WHAT WE ARE SENT FOR, AND YES WE WILL DO 'QITAAL' FOR IT WHEN REQUIRED.

" And Qitaal has been made Fard for you, even if you dislike it" !

Mansur Khurasani said...

//"Read all the constants first, read all the Ayaat first. Contemplate yourself also. Don't feed your mind with one-sided view of scholars of your choice. Get the simple and direct message of Qur'an yourself first."//

I study Quran and Hadith in the light of the explanations of classical scholars and when there is a completely new scenario i refer to their true heirs from the same intellectual tradition. And I believe the situation we currently face is totally unprecedented so i turn back to ulema for guidance...

//"How many Scholars of Tanzeem e Islami, Tehreek e Islami, Al - Qaeda, Hizb ut Tahrir have you listened to yourself?"//

Tanzeeme Islami opposed the operation in Swat and agencies. And it was very right to oppose any operation back in 2004-05 when a dictator stated the evil but now the situation is absolutely different

I dont know much about Tehreek islami

Hizb has nothing substantial with it on this issue. the very institution they think is helping taghoot is their hope for nusrah

Al-Qaeeda: I dont talk about non-existent groups...

Mansur Khurasani said...

//"I know precisely what those scholars said. That by no means goes parallel with what you are presenting here. "//

Please share with all the readers what the ulema said, better with a reference

Muhammad Awais Tahir said...

1- You are free to read any traditional scholar. No true scholar would ever speak against the constants mentioned in the Qur'an and the Hadith. Rationality has to be applied in variables. Where we've been given a ruling to be followed without any excuse, then those who apply rationality to it and reject it, deem themselves to be more intelligent than Allah?

2- Tanzeem e Islami is against the operation still. For tanzeem e Islami all are dictators because all are imposing the secular rule. Tanzeem e Islami is also supporting TTP financially. So, don't make statements about things that you don't know.

3- Yes, Hizb ut Tahrir has that strange thought, but yes they identify them as taghoot 'atleast'.

4- Al-Qaeda is existent, though the paper-work is non-existenet, and that has just been put up by the cIA and Mousaad. Many a times Mousaad agents have been caught running fake Alqaeda camps. These intelligence organizations admitting faking the Osama Bin Ladin video after 9/11. So, yes, they are faking it in paper work and 'official' videos. But, as for the thought it exists, and exists with the very name of Al-Qaeda.

5- Brother, I don't want to lengthen a useless debate her. So, kindly add me up on Muhammad.Awais.Tahir@gmail.com, and bi-izniLLAH we'll have a discussion there.

Muhammad Awais Tahir said...

http://islamandpsychology.blogspot.com/2010/08/holy-quran-and-foreign-policy.html

Anonymous said...

I've read half of this article and I can't take it anymore. A lot of aforementioned facts are wrong. I am a civilian and I've served the institutions of Pakistan Army and Airforce for a reasonable length of time and I had a chance to observe them close. Except a few, most of these people offer Salah regularly and possess much better knowledge of Islam than the author does. I can post a reply comprising of several pages but I won't. The hypocrisy in this article is so evident, the way people like you are trying to mould the minds of innocent people, by first quoting some facts and references from Holy Quran and Ahadith-e-Mubarka and then extending it to your own purpose in a very sanctimonious way. I've been around the globe, and to tell you the truth, Pakistan so far is the only state that adheres to Islam to some extent. And truely speaking it is really the only castle of Islam. If you want to strengthen the castle of Islam, do it with Tableegh and good deeds, the way told to us by Islam. You are no way making this castle stronger by these bomb blasts and infecting the minds of the innocent by incomplete knowledge. The wish to establish a truely Islamic state has prevailed since the end of Khilafat-e-Rashida and has never been truely achieved. The evil always prevails in some way in every society. So in today's world, the best possible solution is to find a balance where Islamic values dominate the evil systems and this can be acheieved in Pakistan and everywhere through Tableegh. A lot of pious people converted millions of people in the subcontinent to Islam. What way did they adopt, bomb blasts or Dawah? May Allah bless all of us with Hidayat and Toufeeq to serve the Muslims in the best possible way.

Asim said...

Anonymous is still roaming in the Makki Period of Islam. Islam Must be implemented in the society not only being practiced. and this can only be done through force. but this doesn't mean to do bomb blast but this must be kept in mind that this all bloodshed is the reaction of what our Army has been doing in tribal areas. i am sure you would too tie a jacket around your neck if your brother, sister, mother or father is being killed by someone provided that they were innocent

Mansur Khurasani said...

@=Tanzeem e Islami is also supporting TTP financially.//

Really? How close have you been to the top brass of Tanzeem? You know them at whatever level, ask them once again. Ask someone responsible and then let us know what you find out. And please I am asking objectively.

@= Al-Qaeda is existent,//

Are you sure? Visit the tribal areas and see people who have been active on both sides of the border and ask them if there is something called Al-qaeeda. Far from internet, in those remote mountains they are far better informed than most of the young bloggers.

And about email contact. That's not a very good idea. You are sharing views in public let me respond in public.

If you are in Islamabad/pindi or Peshawar we can actually meet and if you are ready I can help you visit the actual areas where the 'great game' is being played. I assure you those people in fata are not that weird as people think of them. This will help you a lot in understanding the actual course of events. No militant or military person would harm you, rest is with Allah.

btw, read today's news?

Anonymous said...

OK. Mr. X is in Army as an ordinary soldier, what should he do? Leave the Army? Challenge the seniors/system or what? Please say. Mr. X is in trouble!

Muhammad Awais Tahir said...

@ Mansur

1- I've met Dr Israr Ahmed myself and students who were the closest to him.

2- I've not claimed the existence of Al-Qaeda in the tribal areas that you've visited.

3- I don't wish to respond to useless arguments in public, because people loose the main point in such long discussions. Thats why I delete irrelevant comments.

4- Ok ! You know people of FATA more, that's the not the point here!

5- I was in Islamabad, not now.

Muhammad Awais Tahir said...

@ Anonymous

Mr.X should leave the organization which is directly serving non-muslim cause against muslim, and hence declared itself to be a hypocrite organization according to the Qur'anic definition of the term.

Mr.X should also read this article to remove any remaining doubts :
http://islamandpsychology.blogspot.com/2010/08/holy-quran-and-foreign-policy.html

My advice to Mr.X is to leave this 'job' and join something that has the least possible involvement in strengthening the systems of taghut, and make his main work the struggle for the lost khilafah.

Mansur Khurasani said...

@=Tanzeem e Islami is also supporting TTP financially.//

Really? How close have you been to the top brass of Tanzeem? You know them at whatever level, ask them once again. Ask someone responsible and then let us know what you find out. And please I am asking objectively.

@= Al-Qaeda is existent,//

Are you sure? Visit the tribal areas and see people who have been active on both sides of the border and ask them if there is something called Al-qaeeda. Far from internet, in those remote mountains they are far better informed than most of the young bloggers.

And about email contact. That's not a very good idea. You are sharing views in public let me respond in public.

If you are in Islamabad/pindi or Peshawar we can actually meet and if you are ready I can help you visit the actual areas where the 'great game' is being played. I assure you those people in fata are not that weird as people think of them. This will help you a lot in understanding the actual course of events. No militant or military person would harm you, rest is with Allah.

btw, read today's news?

Muhammad Awais Tahir said...

I know precisely what those scholars said. That by no means goes parallel with what you are presenting here.

But, Yes, Prophet Muhammad prophecized that hypocrite scholars will come, and yes we are living in that age.

One cannot paint everyone with the same brush, don't go to irrational points!

Post a Comment